| 1830 | Logan | Perry | Green |
| 1840 | Logan | Rush | Green |
| 1850 | Logan | Jefferson | Haines, Rea |
| 1850 | Logan | Perry | Clark, Critchfield, Fisher, Green, Harriman |
| 1850 | Logan | Washington | Moon, Richards |
| 1850 | Logan | Zane | Asher, Culver, Garwood, Rea, Spears |
| 1860 | Logan | Perry | Critchfield, Fisher, Green, Harriman |
| 1860 | Logan | West Liberty | Clark, Shaffer |
| 1860 | Logan | Zane | Asher, Rea |
| 1870 | Logan | Perry | Clark, Critchfield, Fisher, Harriman |
| 1870 | Logan | Zane | Asher, Rea |
| 1880 | Logan | Liberty | Clark, Shaffer |
| 1880 | Logan | Perry | Clark, Critchfield, Fisher, Rea |
| 1880 | Logan | Zane | Asher, Rea, Wilson |
| 1900 | Logan | Liberty | Clark |
| 1900 | Logan | Perry | Clark, Critchfield, Fisher, Harriman |
| 1910 | Logan | Bellefontaine | Fisher, Green |
| 1920 | Logan | Bellefontaine | Fisher |
