| 1790 | Westchester | Westchester | Haley |
| 1820 | Broome | Chenango | Haley |
| 1830 | Ulster | New Paltz | Haley |
| 1840 | Ulster | New Paltz | Haley |
| 1850 | Dutchess | Pawling | Mead, Wodin |
| 1850 | Herkimer | Danube | Hammon, Rapps |
| 1850 | Herkimer | Little Falls | Rapps |
| 1850 | Herkimer | Manheim | Gilgert |
| 1850 | New York | New York | Rapps |
| 1850 | Steuben | Greenwood | Mead |
| 1850 | Ulster | Lloyd | Deyer, Haley |
| 1850 | Ulster | Plattekill | Haley, Jones |
| 1855 | Albany | Albany | Haley, Mead |
| 1855 | Ulster | Lloyd | Haley, Jones, O'Conner |
| 1860 | Albany | Albany | Boulett, Haley, Mead |
| 1860 | Onondaga | Pompey | Hatch, Hibbard, Mead |
| 1860 | Ulster | Lloyd | Cozine, Haley, Jones, O'Conner |
| 1865 | Albany | Albany | Haley, Mead, Winne |
| 1865 | Dutchess | Hyde Park | Cozine, Haley |
| 1865 | Dutchess | Poughkeepsie | Haley |
| 1865 | Ulster | Lloyd | Haley, Jones, O'Conner |
| 1870 | Albany | Albany | Haley, Winne |
| 1870 | Dutchess | Hyde Park | Cozine, Haley |
| 1870 | New York | New York | Bastian, Von Hofe |
| 1870 | Onondaga | Pompey | Hatch, Hibbard, Mead |
| 1875 | Dutchess | Hyde Park | Cozine |
| 1875 | Onondaga | Pompey | Hatch, Hibbard |
| 1880 | Albany | Albany | Haley, Winne |
| 1880 | Dutchess | Hyde Park | Cozine |
| 1880 | Dutchess | Hyde Park Village | Haley |
| 1880 | Dutchess | Poughkeepsie | Jones |
| 1880 | New York | Manhattan | Bastian, Von Hofe |
| 1880 | Onondaga | Pompey | Hatch, Hibbard, Mead |
| 1892 | Albany | Albany | Haley, Winne |
| 1892 | Dutchess | Poughkeepsie | Archibald, Haley |
| 1892 | Kings | Brooklyn | Haley, Hatch, Sale |
| 1900 | Albany | Albany | Haley |
| 1900 | Dutchess | Poughkeepsie | Haley, Jones |
| 1900 | Kings | Brooklyn | Haley, Hatch, Hollingshead, Sale |
| 1900 | New York | Manhattan | Bastian |
| 1900 | Onondaga | Manlius | Hibbard |
| 1905 | Albany | Albany | Haley |
| 1905 | Kings | Brooklyn | Haley, Hatch, Sale |
| 1910 | Albany | Albany | Haley, Winne |
| 1910 | Albany | Bethlehem | Winne |
| 1910 | Kings | Brooklyn | Bloodgood, Haley, Hatch, Sale |
| 1910 | Nassau | Hempstead | Higdon |
| 1910 | Queens | New York City | Hollingshead |
| 1910 | Westchester | Mount Vernon | Hoeg, Høgh, Larsen |
| 1920 | Chenango | Norwich | Clark, Hewitt |
| 1920 | Kings | Brooklyn | Bloodgood, Haley, Hatch, Sale |
| 1920 | Nassau | Freeport | Haig, Haley |
| 1920 | Westchester | Mount Vernon | Høgh |
| 1925 | Kings | Brooklyn | Bloodgood, Haley, Hatch, Sale |
| 1930 | Bronx | Bronx | Rapps |
| 1930 | Chenango | Norwich | Clark, Hewitt |
| 1930 | Kings | Brooklyn | Bloodgood, Haley, Hatch, Sale |
| 1930 | Monroe | Rochester | Clark |
| 1930 | Nassau | Hempstead | Haig, Haley |
| 1930 | New York | Manhattan | Hoppe, Schmedtje |
| 1940 | Monroe | Rochester | Clark |
| 1940 | New York | Manhattan | Ring |
| 1940 | Onondaga | Fayetteville | Hatch |
| 1940 | Queens | New York City | Bloodgood, Haley |
| 1940 | St Lawrence | Canton | Haig, Haley |
| 1950 | Kings | Brooklyn | Hatch |
